Civil War n.

Does anybody know what defines a civil war? Let me know if you do. I remember my time in the Navy patrolling the Iraqi oil platforms in the Northern Arabian Gulf. I sat one evening in the bridge of the transport tug from Port Basra lead by an Iraqi captain while the Royal Marines made their security rounds. We talked of life on shore and his hopes for Iraq. He stood smoking his cigarrette and answered some of the questions he had answered a thousand times before. "What is your overall opinion of the presence of Coalition Forces in Iraq." After talking about his family and thanking God for his present well-being, this question broke a gleaming smile. "I hope the Coalition Forces never leave", he replied. "Why?" I asked. "Because when they leave, there will be a civil war." With relatively secure conditions in the southern port town of Basra, he dreaded the day he would have to face his own nation's diverse religious and political factions as they duked it out for the ruling sceptor. Has the civil war begun? I believe many of our own politicians, to include the President himself, as they frequent the scriptures every morning have oft times read the stubbornly prophetic destiny of nations described in ... "A nation divided against itself cannot stand." So why all the debate? Que sera, sera.

2 Comments:
i meant to leave my last message here instead...
cool picture...
I dont know what the exact definition of "Civil War" means. But in my opinion Iraqis have to have some sort of collective identity. If all parties recognize that they are Iraqi first then, tribe, faction, political block, ethicity or whatever second, then it doesn't matter how bitter the conflict or how many lives are lost its not a civil war but only a very serious struggle between Iraqis.
Now on the other hand, if people say, which I believe alot of people say in Iraq now, "to hell with Iraq, I'm going to make sure my fellow Kurds(or Shia or Sunni), who are my highest priority, benifit at the expense or other Iraqis" Then I believe you can call it a civil war.
I think its a civil war now. But I'm more interested in what the Sunnis, Shia, and Kurds themselves think. Would their leaders now answer that it is a civil war. Theirs is the only opinion that matters. When they admit it, the whole world will too.
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home